Quick Staten Island NY MLS Search

Browse All Staten Island NY Historical Properties for Sale

7 Beds 3 Baths 1155883 MLS
Calling all 1031 Exchanges and Investors! Seller is very motivated!! All brick 2 Family semi-attached recently fully renovated and updated buildings close to Empire Outlets and Staten Island Ferry. Truly a great investment property with a projected Cap Rate of 9.5%!! It features 2 walk up apartments with a finished basement and a concrete backyard which can park 6 cars and collect Rental Income of 6 x $150=$900 per month. Unit 1: Level 1+ Finished basement + backyard: 3bd/1ba, kitchen/living/dining combos, granite countertop, solid wood cabinets, plus a finished basement kitchen, 1 full bath, and full tiled floor throughout), has collected rent of $3200/month (proof of rent upon request), currently no lease. Unit 2: Level 2: 4bd/1ba, EIK, granite countertop, solid wood cabinets, spacious living room. Projected Rent: $2800/month, currently vacant. Total rent income: $3200+$2800+$900=$6,900/month, $82,800/yr. Net Operating Expenses: Insurance $5,119.60 + Heat $1,333.57 + Water $1,424.19 + Electricity $998.63 = $10,152. Net Operating Income(NOI): $82,800 - $10,152 =$72,648. It brings ROI (Return Of Investment) 9.5%. All brand new tankless hot water tanks, 1 furnace, separate electricity and gas meters for 2 units, separate electricity and gas meter for basement, finished basement also has storage room. Tenants pay their own utilities. Priced to sell! Won't last!!

164 Brighton Avenue, Staten Island

Listing courtesy of AMERICAN HOMES GROUP.

3 Beds 1 Baths 1155856 MLS
First time to market home on one of the most quaint streets in all of Staten Island. Located in the exclusive neighborhood of Arrochar, a stone's thrown from the Verrazano Bridge, and across the street from the serene greens of Ft. Wadsworth Park. This 3 bedroom ranch sits on a lovely 40x90 lot. Occupied by the family of the original owners, this home has been loved & meticulously cared for. Windows, roof, heating and siding have all been updated. Enter into a wonderful sitting room with gorgeous hardwood floors that extends throughout the entire ground floor. The Enormous Master Bedroom also has a tremendous walk in closet. The 2 additional bedrooms are each equipped with sizable closets. The Full tiled bathroom was renovated just a few years back. Eat-in Kitchen with tile floors, recessed lighting, and plenty of cabinets. Full finished basement offers unlimited options as it can easily accommodate a living area, home office, home gym, and/or whatever your heart desires. Basement also provides access to the backyard. There is a full stand up attic for easily accessible storage. The backyard is green, spacious, tranquil, and perfect for relaxing or entertaining. It has a cabana style patio, an open field, and plenty of potential for upgrades! Not enough can be said about this amazing Arrochar location. It is one of the smallest and quietest streets in all of Staten Island. The bridge is literally 1 minute away. 3 Minute bike ride to the South Beach Boardwalk. Wonderful schools less than a mile away. Several express buses are within a 2 minute walk and due to proximity to the bridge offers the shortest Manhattan commutes you can find. Fort Wadsworth is across the street and is simply amazing with scenic trails, sprawling fields, and is open to the public 7 days a week. Plenty of fine restaurants & shopping just a short drive away. Homes like this are few and far between so take advantage of the opportunity and reach out today to schedule your showing.

12 Galesville Court, Staten Island


1155802 MLS
62 Fillmore Street is a fully detached two family house sitting on a hill facing the water. Wake up in the morning and you will have beautiful water views from both of the second floor front bedrooms. The house is 20 Ft by 43 Ft (Total of 1768 Sq Ft ) and sits on a lot 34 Ft by 110 Ft (3740 Sq Ft ) This house also has a huge two car garage on the first level. On the second floor you will find a large covered porch at the entrance which also faces the water where you can enjoy the delightful breezes. First floor apartment has three bedrooms, an updated kitchen, separate dining room and two full bathrooms. The house has many windows throughout allowing lots of sunlight. There are two staircases which may be used for entry and exit, one at the front of the house and one at the rear of the house. The second floor apartment has four bedrooms, kitchen, a separate dining room, living room and two full bathrooms. There is also a huge attic, the size of the house, that can be accessed from the staircase at the back of the house. Whether you are looking to buy an investment property or you want to live there and have additional income from the rental apartment, this is the house for you. There can be excellent rental income due to the size of the space and also with the large covered parking garage. New Brighton is a beautiful area conveniently neighboring St.George and Tompkinville. It is 1.3 mile to the St George ferry terminal and 1.1 mile from the beautiful Snug Harbor Cultural and Botanical Garden. Call us today to schedule a property tour!

62 Fillmore Street, Staten Island


5 Beds 3 Baths 1155741 MLS
LEGAL 2 FAMILY BEING USED AS A ONE FAMILY. RARE, ''Turn of the Century'' Victorian home, sitting on a 5700 square foot lot, located in the heart of Westerleigh. This is a 2 family home being used as a 1 family. Enter this home through an ''all season'' fully enclosed front porch, with an abundance of windows to maximize sunlight and the cool night breezes. Travel back in time through two Victorian full glass doors into a large foyer rich with ''old world charm'' hardwood floors w/ border inlays, original wood trims, solid wood sliding pocket doors and French doors. The first floor boasts a living room with gas fireplace, formal dining room, eat-in kitchen, with access to the backyard and deck, office/bedroom, and an updated full bathroom. Second floor features an oversized Master Bedroom, three (3) additional generous sized bedrooms and another full bathroom. Walkup finished attic, with heat and A/C, can be used as an additional bedroom or guest suite and a finished basement with a full bath and kitchen provide great options when entertaining and hosting. This home features immaculate hardwood floors throughout the home, abundance of closet space and storage, NEW heating system with 2 zones, Weil Mclain furnace (2022), single layer roof (2016), central air condensers (2019 & 2010), ADT Security System, driveway that can accommodate 5 cars. This is home is a rare find, don't miss out!

175 Wardwell Avenue, Staten Island

Listing courtesy of TOM CRIMMINS REALTY, LTD..

Staten Island Historical Real Estate

Our website features the best real estate search for historical properties available in Staten Island and surrounding areas. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official Realtor®’s database every 15 minutes. 

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire. 

Curious about what’s happening in your neighborhood? You can create a custom market report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold in your neighborhood! 

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!

Contact us today to find out how we can be of assistance to you!